We appreciate your valuable contribution as a reviewer and would like to emphasize key points to strengthen the editorial projection of the journal, consolidating its recognition in the scientific community:

1. Ethical Respect

  • Ensure adherence to ethical principles in the publication of scientific works.

2. Editorial Status of the Journal

  • Familiarize yourself with and align your review process with the editorial scope and mission of the journal.

3. Ethical Review

  • Promptly report any suspicions of plagiarism, data fabrication, or ethical concerns to the Editor-in-Chief or Scientific Council.
  • Maintain strict confidentiality regarding manuscript content and the review process.

4. Evaluation of Manuscript Quality

  • Use the journal's official review form to assess manuscript quality.
  • Provide a brief synthesis expressing your overall impression of the manuscript’s relevance, innovation, and contribution to the field.
  • Offer clear, constructive comments and suggestions to authors, referencing specific pages, paragraphs, or lines.

5. Bibliometric Indicators and Recognition

  • The editorial recognition of the journal is strengthened through indexing and bibliometric impact.
  • Reviewers are encouraged to register their reviews on Publons and ensure their ORCID is up to date, increasing the visibility and acknowledgment of their scientific contribution.

6. Use of Artificial Intelligence

  • Reviewers must not use generative artificial intelligence tools to produce or draft their review reports, as this may compromise confidentiality and the integrity of the evaluation process.
  • Any permitted use of automated tools must remain under human oversight and must not involve the upload or disclosure of confidential manuscript content.

Ponteditora values and acknowledges your dedication to maintaining the scientific and ethical quality of our journal. Thank you for your collaboration.